Awkward boasting

As I was meditating on the Office of Readings for today, it hit me afresh how wrong the Legion response is, i.e. "Look at all the fruit." This is said in a variety of ways: "But we do a lot of good," or "We sincerely want to serve the Church," or "Regnum Christi is all about good works." Perhaps, and I'd like to think everyone is motivated by their own definition of good. But consider this:

The death of the Lord our God should not be a cause of shame for us; rather, it should be our greatest hope, our greatest glory. In taking upon himself the death that he found in us, he has most faithfully promised to give us life in him, such as we cannot have of ourselves.

He loved us so much that, sinless himself, he suffered for us sinners the punishment we deserved for our sins. How then can he fail to give us the reward we deserve for our righteousness, for he is the source of righteousness? How can he, whose promises are true, fail to reward the saints when he bore the punishment of sinners, though without sin himself?

Brethren, let us then fearlessly acknowledge, and even openly proclaim, that Christ was crucified for us; let us confess it, not in fear but in joy, not in shame but in glory.

 

The apostle Paul saw Christ, and extolled his claim to glory. He had many great and inspired things to say about Christ, but he did not say that he boasted in Christ’s wonderful works: in creating the world, since he was God with the Father, or in ruling the world, though he was also a man like us. Rather, he said: Let me not boast except in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ (from a sermon by Saint Augustine).

And let's look again at the Legion/Regnum Christi response:

• They don't say that they are boasting in God's good works through them, but in their own good works (maybe shorthand for the former, but it's always said this way, which indicates sloppy thinking at best) but even if they claim it's God working through them, that's not something to boast about according to Sts. Paul and Augustine;
• Good works--whether God's or man's--are not the point. We can only cling to the cross and pray that we are saved by the blood of Christ;
• "Consider all the good" seems to be the heighth of self-righteousness--and I know I used that phrase myself when in. For this I am truly sorry.

So we can revisit some quotes on behalf of the Legion to see how they stack up:

For his own mysterious reasons, God chose Fr Maciel as an instrument to found the Legion of Christ and Regnum Christi, and we thank God for the good he did. At the same time, we accept and regret that, given the gravity of his faults, we cannot take his person as a model of Christian or priestly life (Legion Communique of 25 March 2010).

Love moves us to continue making a reality of the beautiful and fruitful charism that God gave us. Out of love, we seek to make it bear fruit (Fr Alvaro's letter of 25 March, 2010).

Why would these elderly men attack Father Maciel? Who would conspire to allege sexual misconduct against an aging priest who started a fast-growing priestly congregation, the ecclesial movement Regnum Christi, hundreds of schools, 10 universities, and a host of other institutions and apostolates serving the Church? (Fr Owen Kearns boasting about MM's works, as proof of his goodness).

There have been so many questions in my heart - but I can't doubt the call God put on my heart to join Regnum Christi - and I can't doubt what I have seen of the Holy Spirit working through so many good people: priests, Consecrated, and laity. I also don't deny that I am a sinner myself (RC member defending good people in the Movement -- note the awkward wording).

“While we cannot deny that Father Maciel was our founder and did much good,” the letter says, “neither can we deny the reality of what has recently come to light and his grave human failings."

"Along with the severe failings of the founder, and of the probable few who directly or tacitly enabled those failings over the years, please acknowledge the many good and effective works of the Legion and Regnum Christi, and the thousands of religious vocations in them. The Catholic Church needs and wants to maintain those. I trust Pope Benedict to do that" (comment on article about the Legion).

If you thought the Catholic Church was dead, look again! Fr. Maciel is a true son of the Church, faithful to what God asked of him, and -at 83 years old- is still going strong. This book is candid and historically accurate, showing how a 20 year old seminarian was able to found a religious congregation that is one of the fastest growing in the Church today. "You shall know a tree by its fruits;" for anyone who has heard of the work of the Legionaries of Christ, this book is a chance to see the roots (Ed Mulholland's review of Christ is My Life.

Maciel gives a tearful farewell speech to the congregation: “The Legion is said to be a good work, but what is the chance that the Legion, the tree, the branches, and the fruits are good, but I, the trunk, am evil? What sense is there in that?” (10 October 1956).

"I believe so, the congregation of the Legionaries of Christ is a work that, for me as a priest, I see it as coming from God, that has done a great deal of good, and has to continue doing a great deal of good. I have total confidence that it will continue (Alvaro Corcuera in the radio interview above).

Yes, by their fruits you shall know them, but the fruits are secondary -- not the hook on which you justify your existence. "Who are you calling good?" asked our Lord.

When I survey the wondrous cross
On which the Prince of Glory died
My richest gain I count but loss
And pour contempt on all my pride.

Forbid it Lord that I should boast
Save in the death of Christ my God
All the vain things that charm me most
I sacrificed them to His blood.

When I survey the wondrous cross
On which the Prince of Glory died
My richest gain I count but loss
And pour contempt on all my pride

Forbid it Lord that I should boast
Save in the death of Christ my God
All the vain things that charm me most
I sacrifice them to His blood

From: http://www.musicbabylon.comFrom: http://www.musicbabylon.com

When I survey the wondrous cross
On which the Prince of Glory died
My richest gain I count but loss
And pour contempt on all my pride

Forbid it Lord that I should boast
Save in the death of Christ my God
All the vain things that charm me most
I sacrifice them to His blood

From: http://www.musicbabylon.comFrom: http://www.musicbabylon.com

Comments

[Dilbert]

Consider all the resources they have to work with - $ 20 billion assets, over 800 priests, hundreds of consecrated women and many tens of thousands of volunteers. What do they have to show for all that? Most people where I live have never even heard of them.

[ML]

What fruits did he bring????

He stole people's idea and turned them into apostolate. That was what I thought when I found out Benkovik had your hearth magazine, and I cancel my subscription. What path, what apostolate did MM came up with? maybe I am ignorant. What new way of education did he come up with? something like De la Salle, Don Bosco?
to me every apostolate came up from some good catholic soul to "etablish the Kingdom of God". The only MM did is keeping able men from being ordained within reasonable time, so they would harvest more vocations in South America for the "mouvement". To me the only fruits he came up with, are sins, and they are legions!!!

[Erin Manning]

There's also the oddity that all of the "good works" are so spread out, so redundant (how many different variations of children's clubs do we need, anyway?) and that the Legion connection to its apostolates is sometimes hard to track down.

I've been putting together a list of known Legion affiliates, here:

http://redcardigan.blogspot.com/2010/03/legion-from-alpha-to-zenit.html

I can't help but wonder how many of these groups, etc. are duplicates of work being done by others, and so forth.

[giselle]

Let me clarify, ML. I gave my magazine to Johnnette with my blessing. I wanted to leave it aside at the providential time when she needed a magazine for her Women of Grace. I stayed on as editor for the first year, and then stepped aside to pursue my own writing. Please, never think there was anything untoward in the transferral. She has an excellent apostolate and a real heart for women. As far as I know, she has nothing to do with Regnum Christi.

[reid]

I have grown tired of mmlegion's biological metaphors, but I'll play along. What is the chance that the fruits are good, etc?

Not good. Examine the soil in which the tree has been planted and the nourishment it has received. Under certain ecological conditions plants may become poisonous as the result of accumulation of toxic substances.

[DF]

I never heard of Ed Mulholland, but I bet the poor guy would like that book blurb back. That's one for the ages.

[ML]

Giselle,
Thanks for clearing that up for me. I came across a few apostolates taken over, that I became suspicious for Hearth. I was mistaken.

[DF]

The problem with the fruits argument is that Maciel reduced "fruits" to numbers rather than the practice of theological virtues.

And then of course the Legion infamously makes up all of the numbers. Does anyone seriously believe there were ever 70,000 Regnum Christi members?

[anonymmous]

I believe RC/LC is a counterfeit spirituality. It is not easy to distinguish real fruit from counterfeit "fruit." The only way you can detect a counterfiet is if you have a trained eye - if you know what REAL fruit looks, feels, sounds and tastes like. Real spiritual fruit produces humility. If the RC/LC really studied the spiritual heritage of the Church they would have more ability to see through the flattery and the manipulation. I think the LC purposely take parts of real spirituality and either add to it or subtract from it to use it for their purposes. The litmus test is always humility.

[Cherry]

DF - thank you for pointing out the exaggeration of RC numbers. 70,000?

It would be an enlightening exercise (while we wait the result of the AV?) to quote the membership in our respective regions to ascertain how many RCs there REALLY are. I think we'll find the actual numbers are an inconsequesntial drop in the bucket of the Catholic world.

This will only work if there is good participation.

Any takers?

[Anonymous]

DF,

I also thought that when I read that quote by Ed Mulholland. If he ever had any reputation as a writer or journalist anywhere at all, that is long gone.

Of course, he was probably a minion drummed up from the RC troops and made to feel special when asked to put this book together. He may have had no integrity or journalistic talent at all in the first place, knowing how the LC works.

For all we know, he's a pseudonym, come to think of it. LOL

[Recovering from RC]

Anon @ 10:58, SO TRUE about recognizing counterfeit fruit by knowing TRUE fruit! It wasn't until I was "out" and attended a workshop on Ignatian spirituality by the great - and yes, very humble - Fr. Timothy Gallagher that I finally saw how completely phony the LC version of "spiritual exercises" really is. I could only weep!

Plus, so-called "spiritual direction" was never very spiritual at all, but rather focused on "apostolate" and tattling on the other women. The "program of life" was never really addressed. Even if it were, I now see how insane it is to place such inordinate attention on your weaknesses and "fixing" them through human strength. Ha!

Anyway, the whole fruit argument falls apart for me when realizing that their "spirituality" was nothing but a mirage. The spiritual growth I experienced was by God's grace and in spite of the accident of Regnum/Legion. Thank you, Jesus!

[Kathy]

I accidentally came upon this site and wished I never had but maybe God wanted me to see this. I am a Regnum Christi member now for 6 years and proud of it. The so called "fruits" are very real in my life. When I joined Regnum Christi, I wanted more in my Catholic spirituality and Regnum Christi was and is the answer to it.
My focus is on Christ and Gods will in my life. Plain and simple! How can you spend so much time tearing down something and build a life of Gods peace and tranquility? This site feeds on hate and I am so saddenned to know that you want a movemennt to die because of its founders grave sins. Ask yourself this question- does Jesus want this movement to continue? I know that He is the true founder and knows the Legionaries and Consecrateds beautiful hearts that are for Christ!

[giselle]

Kathy, my sister in Christ, do you want me to copy this note and send it to one of the boys who were molested? They have never received an apology for their suffering -- or for being maligned for years as liars and enemies of Christ. We simply cannot ignore all who have been insulted by the superiors over the years.

Where is charity on their behalf? Where is the integrity of a group that claims to teach love?

[Kathy]

Sure send my letter on to whomever you wish. I would hope and pray that they have been apologized to. Believe me I was sickened when I found out about Marciel and what he did. I pray for those who have been victimized by him, but through my own experiences with the Legionaries and the Consecrated- I have only experienced love, joy, and hope and cannot apologize for that. Christ HAS encountered me through them. There is no doubt in my mind that they are focused on Christ. These priests and Consecrated were lied to just like we all were. They should not have to pay the price for their founder on earth, but if they have to pay the price for Christs sake they will, because they are true soldiers for Christ!

[giselle]

I think the point you're missing is that the ones who lied to them are still in control of the group. We agree on many good points, on the fact that there are many good people, but MM didn't act alone, and we have yet to distinguish who was accountable for the travesty in the name of faith. Until that happens, the lies are still embedded in the system.

[Kathy]

I don't believe that I am missing any points. Regnum Christi has been under investigation and scrutiny and justifiably so- but it's not been shut down. What does that say to me- that Regnum Christi is still very viable because of Jesus Christ himself and the Holy Spirit who is working in each one of us to continue His work!
My daily prayer life has increased dramatically since being in the movement. The fruits in my life do account for something because I know he has a purpose for me and every human being. I am so very blessed to have discovered this movement. The fruits of my life are proof to me that this movement is authentic and truly inspired by Jesus. May God Bless you Giselle and keep you in His care. I am so sorry for any wrongs that have been made to you from the human hands of the movement. I am truly sorry to anyone that has been hurt by the movement. One thing that I have just realized through this site is that there is so much hurt and that I must pray more fervently for the suffering of people who have not only been hurt from the Regnum Christi movement but those who have been hurt by our Catholic priests outside of the movement. May we all be inspired to live in truth, justice, and His truly merciful love that He has for each and every one of us.

[jeff]

Kathy, well said. The faith of my parents, myself, my five brothers and sister, my five children and 18 nieces and nephews exist because a mexican priest came to our "catholic" school and organized an after school soccer game for 5th graders. If any of us make it to heaven it will be thanks to the legion.