Most Helpful Posts

Helpful Articles

Blog powered by Typepad

Comment Policy

  • All constructive comments will be accepted.
    Commenting anonymously is certainly permitted as long as it adds to the understanding of this topic. The point of this site is to foster love for Christ, while analyzing the place of Regnum Christi in the Church. (Please know that no one will be able to track your comments -- neither the readers nor the webmaster. We all understand the hesitancy in speaking about this experience and the fallout that can accrue. All comments will only bear the information you choose to reveal.)

« "difficult to define" | Main | LC comment on the reform »


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference No one is indispensible:


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

You point out another psychological hook - that of having been a selected part of the elite.

This hook is shared by the secret societies of history. There, the initiate is overwhelmed by the power the society exerted.

This hook is more typically coupled with the notion that, for insiders, the world consists of us -- if you aren't one of us, you are nothing.

So, these two lies are usually accepted by the time the person is an active initiate working on their quest for perfection.

Thus, to leave the elite group requires you to overcome two further notions. First the person must realize that the LC claim that they have a superior claim on the Church is a lie. Second, they must accept that they are more powerful without the group. That can be hard to do when the habits of mind made during initiation tell them to measure these questions through the lens the LC gave them.

The LC lens is often repeated here and in any discussions. Look at the good they do for the Church! Look at the movement!

No. The goodness in most cases seems accidental to the LC. Where the goodness isnt merely a nice polished PR piece, it was due to individuals and the grace of God.

That's the secret of the LC. Nobody needs them. Christ doesn't need them. He needs nothing. Rather, He loves each of us and all of us. He can make a rock speak truth, if needed. Do you really think He needs a bunch of self absorbed elites to accomplish anything?

Even though they don't treat their own with dignity, it is only the LC that needs a group of servants that mindlessly do their bidding.

God doesn't want or need mindless people to be beholden to someone in the middle of His relationship with each of us.

Pride: the double edged sword of LC/RC. You point out that pride [or an appeal to pride] was such an important element in the formation, as in 'you are the elites'. Interestingly enough, LC/RC directors/formators/priests/consecrated always say that the issue is your pride if you dare to question, or disagree [oh my!] with what they do or say. I have journeyed as spiritual director/companion with numerous people as they have left RC and among the most difficult issues faced is a skewed sense of pride..what it is and what it isn't. It is just another example of reality being twisting beyond recognition by LC/RC.

Neptune, good words. "To undo this chain of errors is difficult on the psyche" also because one just has to simply let go. And one who has been sucked in are AFRAID TO LET GO. Perhaps they had some insecurity (don't we all) at the beginning that LC latched onto, but assuredly the externalization of all sources of security would make them afraid. I believe that a deep fear is what keeps people tied.

Okay, okay, I said I was leaving, but I have to comment. The women in our section were total geeks and had nothing else going on in their lives. They were nobodies and the LC made them feel wanted. That is IT. They weren't elite, they weren't beautiful, they weren't smart and they weren't all that spiritual. It was all a facade. These women have nothing going on in their lives and that is what the LC preys (not prays) upon. All of the truly good-hearted and intelligent one's have left or are leaving.

It is good to know that some are in the process of leaving. There is hope! And God is good.

Mary Ann,

Fear is exactly what keeps one from getting out. Fear that they were so wrong and so duped. Fear that years were wasted. Fear that they encouraged others. Fear that they let their children be wounded. Fear that they have to carry all that for the rest of their lives! And then the fear for the future, especially if you are consecrated. They have no money, often no real degree, nowhere to go, no career path, no way to survive. Imagine, too, the realization that your relationship with God just might have been a bit less perfect than they thought. (Welcome to human love, I say to that!) But all this is the opposite of what they thought they had "built" for themselves and in their apostolates. This is a tragedy of monumental proportions - especially for the 3gf.

Neptune, to your first comment, above: to leave L/RC nobody has to realize the LC superiority claim is a lie or that they are more powerful without the group. That's part of the healing process. To leave they just have to be told "Get out of here". Hopefully the two other realizations will shortly follwo.

Why can't those in authority in the Church heed the plain words of Cephas and clearly and directly tell members of l/r, "Get out of here"? Instead, Churchly authorities tell those in l/r to stay put on the reservation. Why is that?

(Because the Vatican would have to admit it made a dreadful mistake in allowing l/r to put down roots on Church grounds. Because that would require a whole lot of explaining that the Vatican would prefer not to do. Etc . . .)

The comments to this entry are closed.